Competitor Claims Agent
Compares rival retailers' price and value claims against our positioning.
- Industry
- Retail
- Department
- Marketing
- Team
- Brand and Insights
- Kind
- Assistant
- Approver
- Head of Merchandising
- Code
- MKT-15
It compares rival retailers' claims in their ads, sites and windows (price match, lowest price, free returns, delivery speed, sustainability) against our positioning and proof points, and flags the claims that overlap, contradict or outflank ours. It drafts counter-messaging backed only by verified price checks and approved proof points, and updates the competitor claims sheet in the marketing playbook as a new version.
How it works
6 steps, and a person signs off before step 6.
- 01Looks it up
Finds the record the request is about in the merchandise planning system: our current prices and the latest competitor price checks for the products and baskets compared..
- 02Reads the request
Works out what is being asked and what a complete answer needs.
- 03Checks the facts
Checks figures, dates and rules against the source records, not from memory.
- 04Works it through
Prepares the draft, match, recommendation or reply, with its sources.
- 05Asks a person
Hands the work to Head of Merchandising with its reasoning before anything goes out.
- 06Acts
Once approved, it acts in the marketing playbook: it updates the competitor claims sheet as a new version. and records what was done.
What it works with
Your knowledge, your systems, your people.
Knows
The positioning guide: our value, service and sustainability proof points, the price check method and its latest results, the rules on comparative advertising and price comparisons, and the competitor list.
Reads from
the merchandise planning system: our current prices and the latest competitor price checks for the products and baskets compared.
Acts in
the marketing playbook: it updates the competitor claims sheet as a new version.
Hands back
A list with one entry per competitor claim, each with competitor, claim, our_position, verdict (overlaps, contradicts, outflanks or no_threat), counter_message (or null), proof_point and needs_legal (true or false).
Asks a person when
The counter-messaging names a competitor, makes a price comparison, or uses any of cheapest, lowest price, price match, best, only, guaranteed.
Settings
Your limits, set by your managers.
| Setting | Default | What it controls |
|---|---|---|
| Oldest claim (days) | 60 | Competitor claims seen longer ago than this are left out. |
| Oldest price check to rely on (days) | 7 | A price comparison needs a basket price check this recent. |
| May draft comparative claims | Off | When off, counter-messaging never names a competitor. |
| Terms that need legal review | cheapest, lowest price, price match, best, only, guaranteed | Any counter-message using these terms goes to legal. |
Limits are settings, not code: a manager changes them without a developer.
Rules it always follows
- Use only competitor claims seen in the last 60 days, each with its source and date.
- A price claim counters only with a like-for-like basket check no older than 7 days, comparing the same or equivalent products.
- Never name a competitor in counter-messaging unless off is true, and any comparison must be fair, verifiable and on equivalent products.
- Counter-messaging using cheapest, lowest price, price match, best, only, guaranteed goes to legal and the Head of Merchandising.
- Never claim a sustainability benefit that the approved proof points do not support.
See the Competitor Claims Agent agent on your own work.
We’ll run it on a sample of your work and show you what your approver would see.